Understanding Transformer Cooling Methods: A Comprehensive Guide

As a professional manufacturer of export transformers, we understand that the reliability and longevity of your equipment are paramount. A critical factor determining a transformer's service life is its ability to manage the heat generated during operation. Effective cooling ensures the insulation system remains intact and the unit performs safely under various load conditions.

This guide provides a detailed overview of transformer cooling methods, adhering to international standards (IEC 60076), to help you make an informed decision for your specific application.

Why Cooling is Essential

When a transformer operates, electrical losses (such as I²R losses in windings and eddy current losses in the core) are converted into heat. If this heat is not dissipated efficiently, the internal temperature rises, leading to accelerated degradation of the insulation paper and oil. Overheating is a primary cause of transformer failure. Therefore, selecting the correct cooling method is crucial for maintaining efficiency, reliability, and a long operational life.

Decoding the Cooling Class (IEC 60076)

Cooling methods for liquid-immersed transformers are identified by a standard four-letter code. This code describes the internal cooling medium, its circulation method, the external cooling medium, and its circulation method.

Structure: (Internal Medium) (Internal Circulation) (External Medium) (External Circulation)

First Letter - Internal Cooling Medium: O (Mineral oil or synthetic insulating liquid with flashpoint ≤ 300°C) / K (Insulating liquid with flashpoint > 300°C) / L (Insulating liquid with no measurable flashpoint)

Second Letter - Internal Circulation Mechanism: N (Natural thermosiphon flow through the cooling system and windings) / F (Forced circulation through the cooling system, but thermosiphon flow in windings) / D (Forced circulation directed through the main windings)

Third Letter - External Cooling Medium: A (Air) / W (Water)

Fourth Letter - External Circulation Mechanism: N (Natural convection) / F (Forced circulation—fans for air, pumps for water)

Below are the most common cooling methods you will encounter.

1. ONAN (Oil Natural Air Natural)

Common Name: Oil-Immersed Self-Cooled

This is the most fundamental and widely used cooling method, especially for smaller distribution transformers (typically up to tens of MVA).

How it works: Heat generated by the core and coils causes the oil to rise naturally to the top of the tank. This hot oil flows through external radiators or cooling tubes. As the oil travels down the radiator, it dissipates heat to the surrounding air through natural convection and radiation. The cooled oil then re-enters the bottom of the tank, creating a continuous natural circulation.

Advantages: Simple, robust, highly reliable, and requires no auxiliary power for cooling.

Applications: Ideal for continuous base-load operations and locations where maintenance must be minimal.

2. ONAF (Oil Natural Air Forced)

Common Name: Oil-Immersed Forced-Air Cooled (or Oil-Immersed Air-Blast)

To increase the cooling capacity without enlarging the radiator bank, fans are added.

How it works: This method builds upon the ONAN principle. The oil still circulates by natural convection. However, the heat exchange process on the radiator surface is accelerated by one or more fans that blow air forcefully across the cooling surfaces.

Advantages: Significantly increases the transformer's rated capacity (often by 20-40% compared to ONAN) without a major increase in size. Many transformers have a dual rating: ONAN for base load and ONAF for peak loads.

Applications: Medium to large power transformers where load variations are expected.

3. OFAF (Oil Forced Air Forced)

Common Name: Forced Oil Forced Air Cooled

As transformer sizes increase, relying on natural oil convection becomes insufficient. This method introduces pumps to accelerate the oil flow.

How it works: Oil pumps (also known as positive displacement pumps) are installed in the piping between the main tank and the air-blast coolers. These pumps force the hot oil from the top of the tank through the coolers at a high velocity. Fans simultaneously force air over the cooler surfaces. This combination dramatically increases the heat transfer rate.

Advantages: Very high cooling efficiency, allowing for compact designs for large power ratings.

Applications: Large power transformers, generator step-up units (GSUs), and industrial furnace transformers.

4. OFWF (Oil Forced Water Forced)

Common Name: Forced Oil Forced Water Cooled

When air cooling is impractical due to space constraints or environmental conditions (like in underground substations or on offshore platforms), water cooling is employed.

How it works: Hot oil is forced by pumps through an oil-to-water heat exchanger (cooler). Cooling water, typically from a dedicated cooling tower or a natural source, is forced through the exchanger to remove the heat from the oil. A critical design feature is that the oil pressure must be maintained higher than the water pressure. This ensures that if a leak develops, oil leaks into the water, rather than water contaminating the transformer's insulating system.

Advantages: Extremely efficient and allows for a very compact cooling system footprint.

Applications: Hydroelectric plants, underground substations, and high-capacity urban power centers.

5. ODAF / ODWF (Oil Directed Air/Water Forced)

Common Name: Directed Oil Flow Cooled

This is the most advanced cooling method for the largest power transformers. Standard forced oil cooling (OF) may still leave "hot spots" within the windings.

How it works: In a directed flow design (D), the forced oil is not just circulated in the tank but is specifically channeled to flow directly through the windings themselves via strategic piping and guides. This ensures that the cooling medium makes direct contact with the hottest parts of the winding conductors, extracting heat much more effectively.

Advantages: Maximizes heat transfer from the windings, minimizing hot spot temperatures and allowing for the highest possible power densities.

Applications: Extremely large power transformers, EHV and UHV transformers where managing hot spots is critical for reliability.

How to Choose the Right Cooling Method

Selecting the appropriate cooling system is a strategic decision based on several factors:

Load Profile and Capacity:

Light to Medium Loads: ONAN is often sufficient and most economical.

Cyclic or Peak Loads: An ONAN/ONAF dual-rated transformer offers the benefits of both worlds—efficiency at low load and extra capacity when needed.

High Continuous Loads: For large, continuously operating units, OFAF or OFWF provides the necessary continuous cooling capacity.

Environmental Conditions:

High Ambient Temperature: Forced air methods (ONAF, OFAF) are necessary to maintain a sufficient temperature differential for heat exchange.

Confined or Humid Spaces: Water cooling (OFWF) is ideal for indoor or underground installations where ventilation for air cooling is poor.

Arid or Water-Scarce Regions: Air-cooled methods (ONAN, ONAF, OFAF) are the only viable choices.

Maintenance and Operational Costs:

Initial Investment vs. Lifecycle Cost: While ONAN has the lowest initial cost, OFAF and OFWF involve pumps, fans, and controls, leading to higher installation and maintenance costs. However, they enable a smaller transformer footprint for a given rating, which can offset the initial capital expenditure.

Conclusion

Understanding these cooling methods is essential for optimizing your electrical infrastructure. As a professional manufacturer with 15-year experience, AISITE specializes in designing and manufacturing transformers tailored to your specific operational needs. 

Welcome to contact us to discuss your project requirements and find the suitable cooling solution for your transformer needs.

📧 Email: [sale@aisite-ast.com]
📞 Phone/Whatsapp/Wechat: [+86 15896663407]
🌐 Website: [https://www.aisite-ast.com/]